CBI under a cloud after acquittal of Parents in Arushi case

Time and again people dissatisfied with investigation of a case by the local police have approached the authorities and courts to order a CBI investigation in the belief and expectation that the result would lead to an unbiased and fair result. Yet the CBI has often been accused of being subject to pressure and incomplete presentation of facts of the case.

The latest cause for such a view is the acquittal and release of Dr. Rajesh Talwar and his wife, Dr. Nupur Talwar, on Monday, October 16, after they had spent four years in Ghaziabad’s Dasna jail for the alleged murder of their daughter, Aarushi, and domestic help, Hemraj.

The two dentists were acquitted by the Allahabad High Court in the second week of October on an appeal against their conviction by a lower court, on the ground that “the prosecution has failed to prove its case against the accused appellants beyond all reasonable doubts”. The family of the two dentists say “full justice is awaited” as the investigating agencies had failed to find the killer. “The killers are still out. The Allahabad High Court has mentioned in its order, page 227 onwards”, according to Group Captain B.G.Chitnis (retired), who is the father of Dr. Nupur Talwar.

Yet the CBI is preparing the grounds for an appeal against the High Court’s verdict to defend its legal position in the case. The question is whether the Supreme Court will ask it to go back to the High Court to seek a review of its verdict, or will the case be dragged to the Supreme Court in a public interest litigation by non-governmental agencies or institutions seeking to protect the interests of children. Since the Supreme Court has repeatedly criticized publicity seeking people approaching it, will the apex court inquire of those approaching it whether there was a constitutional issue or a fundamental right was being infringed in this case.

There has also been much media hype over the Aarushi murder case and a lot of hot air rather than any genuine discussion after the High Court verdict. Is that the case with a number of current issues by self-appointed experts analysing points and counter-points with news channel anchors trying to thrash issues.

Yet the High Court has criticized the doctors who conducted the post-mortem of Aarushi and Hemraj for introducing the “sexual intercourse theory” as motive for the double murder “without an iota of evidence” and one of the doctors citing “marital experience” for his observation. But the doctor who conducted the post-mortem nine years ago after the murders is alleged to have told a Times of India newspaper reporter that he had been convinced about the theory put forward by a CBI investigator. He claimed that he was not an expert in conducting a post-mortem. This had been imposed on us”. He was a paediatrician at a super speciality institute.


Lalit Sethi is a Journalist of long standing and a commentator on Political and Social Issues.

Review Date
Reviewed Item
CBI under a cloud after acquittal of Parents in Arushi case
Author Rating
Opinion Poll
With assembly election ahead With assembly election ahead, well known Digital Media platform has decided to gauge the mood of Chhattisgarh through its own opinion poll. As an aware voter and stakeholder of the democratic process, kindly do answer the following questions so that prevailing mood of state can be ascertained.
Assembly Segment
Phone Number
Which party will emerge as the single largest party?
Which party will win how many seats?
Whom would you like to see as next Chhattisgarh Chief Minister?
Have you witnessed development work in your area?
Do you think that farmers of Chhattisgarh are satisfied with BJP government?
Do you think youngsters are happy with employment scenario created by Chhattisgarh/state government?
Do you think state government has done enough on issue of women empowerment?
Are you satisfied with work done by your legislator? Have electoral promises been fulfilled or not?
Are you satisfied with the amenities provided by the government in your area?
Do you think the state government has successfully tackled naxal menace?
Are you satisfied with work done by different state Ministers?

Please do vote...

ओपिनियन पोल
छत्तीसगढ़ की आगामी विधानसभा चुनाव के लिए डिजिटल मीडिया ‘’ नेसटीक ओपिनियन पोल करनेका निश्चय किया है. अतः आप नीचे दिए सवालों के निष्पक्ष जवाब देंताकि राज्य की आने वाले दिनों की सही सियासी तस्वीर सामनेआ सके. कृपया अपना मत जरूर दें- With assembly election ahead
विधानसभा क्षेत्र
फ़ोन नं
विधानसभा चुनाव में सबसे बड़ी पार्टी कौन सी होगी ?
किस पार्टी को कितनी सीटें मिलेगी?
अगले मुख्यमंत्री के रूप में किसे देखना चाहेंगे?
क्या आपके क्षेत्र में विकास दिखाई पड़ रहा है?
क्या छत्तीसगढ़ का किसान भाजपा शासन से संतुष्ट है?
जो रोजगार छत्तीसगढ़ सरकार ने दिया, क्या उससे युवा वर्ग संतुष्ट है?
राज्य सरकार ने महिलाओं के सशक्तिकरण के लिए जो किया, उससे महिलाएं संतुष्ट हैं?
क्या आप अपने विधायक से संतुष्ट हैं? उन्होंने अपने वादे पूरे किए या अधूरे हैं उनके काम?
क्या आप अपने क्षेत्र की सरकारी सुविधाओं सेसंतुष्ट हैं?
क्या नक्सली समस्या पर नियंत्रण हुआ है?
क्या प्रदेश के मंत्रियों के कामकाज से संतुष्ट हैं?
-देश हित के लिए मतदान अवश्य करें-

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.